Seeing the Scene
What could the courtroom look like in ten or fifteen years? Part two: putting a place in front of a jury instead of a picture of one.
In a prior article, I reviewed emerging technologies that I researched for my thesis at Duke Law's Bolch Judicial Institute. That article reviewed technologies likely to impact criminal procedure in the future. Those five were primarily about information and what might be learned before a trial begins, which covered suspects, witnesses, bail, and even jurors.
Here I turn to the courtroom and to the presentation of evidence. The three that follow all do the same thing in different ways. Each one puts a place in front of a jury instead of a picture of a place. Some of them have already arrived in the courtroom.
6. Crime Scenes Preserved in 360 Degrees
Most of us have likely seen 360-degree or panoramic photography without giving it much thought. We most often see it when shopping for a car or a house on a computer or phone. This photography allows us to look around a car or a room from one stationary position, as if we were actually there. We can turn all the way around and see everything.
In a home, this happens when a camera is placed in a stationary position, usually on a tripod, in the middle of a room, and records in every direction, from floor to ceiling and wall to wall. The camera is then repositioned in another room, and the process repeats. The images are eventually linked together, and the observer can experience walking through the entire home. The National Institute of Justice has studied similar systems built for crime scenes, which also measure the distance to every surface so the record preserves the space's true dimensions.
The same technology can be used in a courtroom. Instead of a group of individual photographs, crime scene investigators could preserve an entire room, its dimensions, and how it appeared when they arrived, and then present it to a jury. Jurors with computer screens or tablets could observe the entire crime scene from their seats in the courtroom. If allowed, jurors could look around the room individually, turning left or right, looking behind them or above them. Each juror could point out what they want other jurors to see during deliberations. Instead of the jury going to the scene, the scene might come to the jury. If a jury wants to consider the dimensions of a room when weighing self-defense, might this technology help, or might it be considered prejudicial?
A photograph directs jurors to look at what held the photographer's attention. A 360-degree scene lets the jury choose where to look, which might include something the lawyers did not see or something they did not want distracting the jurors.
7. Virtual Reality
In December of 2024, Judge Andrew Siegel of Broward County, Florida, donned a virtual reality headset while seated on the bench to view a defense expert's presentation during a stand-your-ground hearing. This use of virtual reality by a judge was the first known instance of its kind in an American courtroom. In that case, the judge was the fact finder. Might this experience someday extend to a jury?
Virtual reality is similar to 360-degree photography. In each scenario, the user views an entire location from a fixed position and experiences the setting as if they were physically present. One major distinction separates them. Virtual reality is entirely a created or recreated environment, while 360-degree photography is a recorded one. Virtual reality can also place objects in motion rather than represent a single moment in time.
Take the setting of an automobile accident, a crime scene, or a construction site. Could jurors one day put on headsets, as Judge Siegel did, and see a virtual scene of a car running a red light? Might the safety procedures at a construction site be recreated while jurors watch an expert's explanation, or an attorney's version of the facts during closing argument? If so, might this become a question of whether the party with deeper pockets, better resources, and the best production quality becomes the more persuasive one? It could also create a new position in law firms, a virtual evidence reproduction technician, and that position may become essential to trial work.
8. Augmented Reality, and Eventually Holograms
While virtual reality creates a new room and environment, augmented reality changes the room and environment you are already in. Pokémon Go is an example many people experience. In this game, users walk around their homes or neighborhoods holding up a phone that shows Pokémon characters appearing to be present in real life. The phone's camera uses images of the room and places the character’s image on the screen. The Pokémon appears to be present with the player.
This is now used in other more practical ways. Amazon Prime and furniture stores sometimes allow shoppers to use augmented reality to see how a piece of furniture fits in a room before they buy it. A more serious version is already used in operating rooms, where images are laid over a patient during a procedure to guide the surgeon.
In a courtroom, the presentation would not come from the monitor on the wall because a shared screen can show only one camera's view and amounts to ordinary video. Instead, augmented reality would come from a tablet the court provides to each juror. Each juror could aim their tablet in a particular direction to observe the same thing. Eventually, glasses could replace the tablets. A medical expert might place a three-dimensional injury where the jury can see it from every side, vehicles might move through an accident reconstruction in the middle of the well, and figures might stand where witnesses say people were standing. A juror in the second row would see the same object from a different angle than a juror in the first.
Augmented reality would allow a juror to observe an exhibit in a way a photograph cannot. The limitation, though, is that what is seen is only as good as the measurements and the assumptions used to build it. The question becomes whether the jury weighs the evidence that supports the model or weighs the model itself.
Eventually the glasses may disappear. Holographic telepresence already lets a life-size remote person appear in a room where they are not standing, and speak and answer questions as though present, which is augmented reality without anything worn on the face. The engineering problem there is different. A headset shows one viewer one image, while a figure standing in the well of a courtroom has to be correct for twelve points of view at once.
Each of these three changes where a jury's attention can go. A photograph, a diagram, and a video all show a jury what someone else selected. A scene a jury can look around, step into, or walk past hands part of that choice to the jury itself.
None of the three requires anything new to be invented. They are all already here, and they will only improve and become more widely used. The last two on my list are not about a place at all. They are about people, and I will cover them in the next article.