Future · The Courtroom in Ten or Fifteen Years

What Could the Courtroom Look Like in 10 or 15 Years?

Five of ten emerging technologies, and what they may ask of the courts.

I've been a judge for twenty years. When I started in 2006, few people would have imagined the technology that is now a part of an ordinary day in court. Today, we routinely see photographs taken with phones, screenshots of text messages, surveillance video, and location data showing where someone was at a particular time. In civil cases, it is customary to see whether a driver sent a text message just before an accident and what was typed.

I'm currently completing my work with the Judicial Studies Program at Duke University School of Law. As part of preparing for my thesis, I began looking at emerging technologies and their potential impact on the courts of the future. Instead of 20 years, I looked at the next 10 years. Some of what I found revealed not only what the next ten or fifteen years may bring, but what’s already here. I reduced it to ten. It may seem extremely futuristic, but some of the tech already exists.

Here are 5 of the 10.

1. Artificial Intelligence and Bond Decisions

Risk-assessment tools are already a part of the pretrial system. The federal judiciary uses a Pretrial Risk Assessment tool. Mecklenburg County uses the Public Safety Assessment, and Wake County also uses tools. Right now, those tools provide information to the decision-maker.

What if artificial intelligence eventually produces a recommended bond amount and conditions of release? Might a legislature someday create a statewide system, or contract with an artificial intelligence vendor for a system that tells judges what the bond should be? And if so, would judges then have to make findings explaining why they departed from the recommendation? The information could be as detailed as desired and based on their priorities.

We already follow factors and standards given by the legislature. Could they just take it a step further to limit judicial discretion?

2. Simpler Electronic Monitoring During Pre-trial Release

When most people think of electronic monitoring, they think of a bulky ankle bracelet. Smartwatches already do much more than count steps. They can track location, movement, and give a variety of information.

Will court-ordered monitoring eventually become as simple as wearing a watch or a ring? Could monitoring expand so that every person released before trial or on parole receives one? Could monitoring currently used only in certain cases become temporary and routine because the device is cheap, unobtrusive, and easy to use?

For some, that might reduce the social stigma of wearing a large ankle bracelet. It might also make electronic monitoring much more common.

3. Facial Recognition for Witnesses, Not Just Suspects

We are familiar with facial recognition on our phones. We have become familiar with facial recognition of criminal suspects from television and airports. We usually think of it as a way to identify a suspect. What if it's used not only to identify the suspect but also to identify witnesses?

Could you receive a subpoena because a system determined that you were standing near a crime scene? Might an officer knock on your door or show up at work to ask you questions because you were identified as being nearby when something happened? Could you be a person of interest?

If the technology can identify a suspect, there is no technological reason it cannot identify a witness.

4. Facial Recognition During Jury Selection

There are more surprising ways that facial recognition may be used. In 2024, two Harvard students combined Meta smart glasses with facial-search engines, artificial intelligence, and public databases. They could identify strangers walking down the street and retrieve information about them simply by looking in their direction.

Perhaps that will find its way into the courtroom during jury selection. Some firms already have assistants who will research jurors as soon as they have a name. Now, imagine an attorney wearing smart glasses looking at a juror and immediately learning about the person's public social-media posts, interests, organizations, and other publicly available information. Today, it usually requires a laptop, a phone, or someone sitting nearby to do the research. Could it happen instantly and invisibly without anyone knowing? Would judges prohibit lawyers from using those glasses during jury selection? Could someone already have similar glasses for other scenarios? Will there eventually be do-not-recognize lists like do-not-call lists to protect us whether in the jury box or walking down the street?

5. Deepfakes and Digital Impersonation

I think many of us are already worried about deepfakes in politics. The personal impact in the courtroom may be just as important. The phone evidence I described earlier could be altered. Could a phone message with someone making a threat be real, or an AI-generated replication? Could an image be changed so that the object in someone's hand appears to be a gun instead of a phone? Or could a person be placed in a location where that person was never actually present?

I recently used an AI avatar that looked like me and sounded somewhat like me. That was basically a cheap demonstration. What would someone do if their life is on the line? Courts may increasingly have to ask not only whether evidence is reliable, but whether the event depicted ever happened at all.

What’s Next?

I thought I was trained until I actually received the training, and then I learned how much more there is to learn. Many judges have not had that or any training yet.

We tend to think of the future as distant. Tomorrow is the future. The emerging technology I've described may appear in court very soon.