A History of the North Carolina Trial Court System
The colony lays the foundation.
The Colony Lays the Foundation
Recently, I researched the history of the NC Court system for a project that I never pursued. Instead of leaving the sources and notes in folders on my computer, I have decided to put them to use in what I hope is a series of separate articles. I will not include the full three and a half centuries of what I found, but some was too interesting not to share. There are parts of North Carolina’s court history worth telling and other aspects that should not be forgotten. The cases are an interesting comparison but also reveal the foundations of the system and the lives behind that development. For now, I’ll start with the basic structure and, hopefully, follow it through to the present. I’ve included sources at the end if you want to do your own research.
North Carolina’s courts began when the colony existed as a land grant from the King of England. In March of 1663, Charles II declared that the large stretch of land be granted to eight men who had helped him regain the English throne following his recent exile. The claimed territory was expanded even more two years later.1
The charter issued originally by Charles I called the province Carolana, from Carolus, the Latin for Charles, meaning “land of Charles.” In 1663, the new charter carried the name forward as Carolina.
Charles II dubbed the eight men its “true and absolute Lords Proprietors”:
-
Edward Hyde, Earl of Clarendon
-
George Monck, Duke of Albemarle
-
William Craven, Earl of Craven
-
John Berkeley, Lord Berkeley
-
Anthony Ashley Cooper, Lord Ashley
-
Sir George Carteret
-
Sir William Berkeley
-
Sir John Colleton
Their names and family names still appear in the names of streets and areas across the North Carolina map, such as Albemarle Sound and Hyde, Craven, and Carteret counties. None of them ever lived in Carolina. Sir William Berkeley served as governor of Virginia, and Sir John Colleton had lived and planted in Barbados.2
In 1669, the proprietors adopted the Fundamental Constitutions of Carolina, a detailed plan of government based principally on the ideas of the philosopher John Locke, who worked for Anthony Ashley Cooper.3 The document announced itself as “the sacred and unalterable form and rule of government of Carolina forever.”4 It laid the foundation for a grand aristocracy, hereditary privilege, a working class of tenants, and high courts for each province. Implementation never met this idealism, though. The actual colony held only a few hundred farming families, scattered throughout the marshy northeastern corner of North Carolina. Instead of courts in seats of power, small working courts began instead: justices’ courts and precinct courts, a General Court, a Court of Chancery, and a court of oyer and terminer, a special commission to hear and determine the most serious crimes.5 The new society did not bring a set system with them from England. Instead, the courts were created from English legal customs adapted to local conditions, with local men of higher social standing sitting in judgment.6
The system that eventually formed included a General Court that stood at the top of the colony’s common-law court system. It heard larger civil and criminal matters and also reviewed cases coming from the lower courts, while equity developed separately in the Court of Chancery. For years, the governor and his council played central roles in the higher courts.
In 1685, the proprietors told the governor to appoint four “able, discreet men” as justices, along with a sheriff, but it took more than ten years to make that happen. The office of chief justice was formally created in 1712. He led a group of associates whose numbers often changed.7 The court met only a few times a year and handled a variety of cases: felony trials, large civil cases, appeals, and jail deliveries.8 Because there was no fixed capital for many years, the court met wherever the government happened to be at that time.
Most people never saw the General Court but dealt with the precinct court. When the system of designating territories as counties began in 1738–39, the precinct courts became the county courts. Later, the official name became the Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions, reflecting the fact that the justices of the peace met four times a year. These sessions handled the everyday business of the county: settling debts, dealing with minor offenses, arranging for orphans to be bound out to masters, proving wills, licensing taverns and ferries, and laying out roads.
Local landowners, with no required legal training, served as justices. They were not professional judges and relied on custom and common sense as much as any law book. Court was held wherever a quorum could conveniently assemble, often in a private home, until a courthouse was built. By the 1730s, the smallest debts did not even have to go before the full court; a single justice could handle certain small claims alone.9
For most free colonists, the system centered on the General Court above and the precinct or county courts below. In addition to these courts, the governor and council sat as the Court of Chancery, the Admiralty Court handled maritime matters, and individual justices handled smaller cases, along with other specialized tribunals.
Beginning in 1715, enslaved defendants were increasingly subjected to a separate court process that denied them many of the protections available in the ordinary courts. That is the topic of the next article.
Sources
- The First Charter Granted by King Charles the Second to the Lords Proprietors of Carolina, 24 March 1663, reprinted in The Colonial Records of North Carolina, ed. William L. Saunders (Raleigh: P. M. Hale, 1886), vol. 1, 20–33; The Second Charter Granted by King Charles the Second to the Proprietors of Carolina, 30 June 1665, reprinted in The Colonial Records of North Carolina, vol. 1, 102–114. The 1663 charter designates the eight grantees “true and absolute Lords and Proprietors.”
- “Lords Proprietors,” NCpedia (Government and Heritage Library, State Library of North Carolina) (identifying the eight proprietors and describing their connections to the New World); on the earlier use of the name Carolana and its derivation from Carolus, see “Carolana,” NCpedia, and N.C. Department of Natural and Cultural Resources materials on the 1629 grant.
- William J. Adams, “Evolution of Law in North Carolina,” 2 N.C. L. Rev. 133, 133–34 (1924); The Fundamental Constitutions of Carolina, reprinted in The Colonial Records of North Carolina, vol. 1, 187–205. Several versions of the Constitutions circulated in 1669; one version was signed and sealed by the proprietors on 21 July 1669.
- The Fundamental Constitutions of Carolina (1669), final article, reprinted in The Colonial Records of North Carolina, vol. 1, 187–205; on the proposed aristocratic structure, including landgraves and caciques, see “Peerage,” NCpedia.
- Adams, at 134 (describing how the elaborate proposed governmental structure gave way in practice to justices’ courts, precinct courts, the General Court, the Court of Chancery, and courts of oyer and terminer).
- On the development of the early courts from English legal traditions adapted to local conditions and the role of local justices, see Paul M. McCain, The County Court in North Carolina Before 1750 (Durham: Duke University Press, 1954), and John L. Sanders, A Brief History of the Courts of North Carolina, in North Carolina Courts of Law and Equity Prior to 1868 (1959).
- State Archives of North Carolina, Colonial Court Records Group, 1665–1787, SR.401 (describing the organization of the General Court and stating that the office of chief justice was created in 1712); Adams, at 135–36.
- State Archives of North Carolina, Colonial Court Records Group, 1665–1787, SR.401 (describing the General Court’s original and appellate jurisdiction); Adams, at 135–36 (describing the court’s jurisdiction over serious civil and criminal matters and its functions in Oyer and Terminer and General Gaol Delivery).
- Paul M. McCain, The County Court in North Carolina Before 1750; John L. Sanders, A Brief History of the Courts of North Carolina; Adams, at 136 (describing the county courts and the role of justices of the peace). On the statutory authority for individual justices to hear small claims, see An Act for the Tryal of small and mean Causes, in A Collection of All the Public Acts of Assembly, of the Province of North-Carolina, Now in Force and Use 145 (James Davis 1751), reflecting the colonial practice of assigning certain lower-value disputes to individual justices rather than the full county court.