Past · History of the North Carolina Trial Court System

North Carolina's Slave Courts

A separate tribunal, built for people the law considered property.

The courts described in the last article had a counterpart. The second system is rarely discussed because it was built for people the law considered property. Beginning in 1715, an enslaved person accused of a serious crime generally did not go before the General Court or a county court with a jury. Instead, the accused went to what has been referred to as the “Slave Court.”

The system was created when North Carolina had a smaller enslaved population, but it became part of the government of a slave society. In 1712, there were approximately 800 enslaved people in North Carolina. By 1764, North Carolina’s population had grown to an estimated 30,000 enslaved Black residents and 114,000 white residents.1

The 1715 law authorized three justices of the precinct court to sit with three freeholders. The senior justice selected the time and place of trial sessions. The hearing was not required to take place in a courthouse. Sessions could be held where deemed appropriate, including a local planter’s home. No jury of enslaved peers or free residents sat. A simple majority of the six men could impose punishment affecting “life or Member,” including whipping, mutilation, or death.

The requirement that slaveholders participate carried its own contradiction. Ernest James Clark later described it as a possible protection for the accused. His theory was that slaveholders would understand the circumstances of slavery. It also reflects the slaveholders’ interest in preserving what they regarded as labor and property. Clark further suggested that the requirement may have excluded Quakers and others who opposed slavery from serving on the panel. Ultimately, the law placed an enslaved defendant’s fate in the hands of men who had a direct property interest in maintaining the institution.2

The legislative assembly revised the system in 1741 and further formalized it. Three justices and four freeholders who owned enslaved people could then try the accused “without the Solemnity of a Jury.” The justices came from the county’s justice-of-the-peace structure, and hearings were now held at the county courthouses. County clerks recorded the tribunal’s orders. Sheriffs and constables confined defendants and carried out sentences. They could determine guilt, select the punishment, and order its execution, often in a single proceeding. The change allowed those suspected of criminal activity to be jailed while the tribunal was assembled.

Though the Slave Court provided a judicial hearing, it also held an economic consequence. Preparing for a full trial like one afforded to a free person required time and expense, and confinement deprived the enslaver of labor. A summary hearing reduced the slave owner’s losses and returned the accused to work quickly unless the sentence made that impossible.3

Additionally, the slave code served a broader purpose than resolving criminal accusations. Both the 1715 and 1741 laws addressed the social structure of a society with slavery by establishing and maintaining its racial hierarchy and power structure. The laws further entrenched racial differences in legal privilege through restrictions on travel, trade, social contact, property ownership, and access to weapons. These laws sought to reduce escapes, discourage relationships between enslaved and white people, and suppress conduct that white residents perceived as threatening. In Clark’s assessment, the code operated both as a police system and as a means of establishing a distinct racial order within the community.4

The abbreviated sessions used familiar courtroom terms and phrases from English common law in the prosecutions of the defendants who were likely first- or second-generation enslaved residents of the English colonies. For some defendants and witnesses, the language used in the proceeding may not have been their native language. The procedures were similar to those afforded in the General Court or county courts, but the application was not. Tribunal members took an oath to decide the controversy between the king and “the Prisoner at the Barr” according to “the Truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.” Enslaved witnesses played a vital role in these prosecutions, even though their testimony generally was inadmissible in cases involving white or free Black people. One example noted the continuation of an ongoing trial until more witnesses could be gathered.5

Most punishments could vary because there was no structured sentencing scheme. In 1729, legislation authorized as many as forty lashes for an enslaved person found away from the customary road or visiting at night. A captured runaway might be passed from constable to constable on the journey back after a justice had ordered as many as thirty-nine lashes.6

One noted example revealed that enslaved informants might receive preferential treatment even if found guilty of the charged offense. In Pasquotank County, an enslaved man named Jack was discharged after agreeing to reveal “all the intrigues of his Comrades” and provide evidence against them.

The punishments reveal both the cruelty of the system and the disparate treatment of accused enslaved people. Imprisonment meant lost labor, so bodily punishment that allowed a person to return to work supported the economic structure of slavery. Whipping was the customary punishment and was often combined with branding or mutilation. For hog stealing, an enslaved man named Bob received twenty-five lashes in Craven County. In Pasquotank County, Mingo received one hundred lashes and the severing of both ears for the same offense.7

The case of Judith shows what the language of corporal punishment meant. Judith, an enslaved woman, was accused of approaching her enslaver, Judith Boyce, with an axe. The tribunal ordered her right ear nailed to the whipping post for ten minutes and then cut off, followed by forty lashes on her bare back.8 The record preserves the accusation and punishment, but not Judith’s account or any defense offered for her.

The 1741 code did not require a completed murder for a death sentence. If the Slave Court found that three or more enslaved people conspired to rebel, make insurrection, or commit murder, they could be convicted of a capital felony. Planning was enough.9

The monetary significance of slavery was intricately woven into the system of sentencing and punishment. In 1758, the legislature directed that a male enslaved defendant convicted of another capital offense be castrated rather than executed for a first offense, except for murder or rape. The sheriff received twenty shillings for performing the operation, and three pounds could be allowed from public funds for treatment. The court appraised the condemned man beforehand so that his owner could be compensated if he died.10 When an enslaved person was executed or died from judicial punishment, the enslaver could also be compensated for the loss of property. In 1769, the clerk of New Hanover County was allowed seven pounds for seven people executed, a pound for each. The next year, an owner named Richard Browning collected 216 pounds for three people executed together for felony.11

The court system today has a role in establishing our social norms and standards. The same was true from North Carolina’s colonial beginnings. It was not a system founded upon fairness, the equal application of the law, or justice for all. North Carolina’s colonial government did not construct one system of justice while tolerating a shadow Slave Court lurking in a hidden society outside the government. The Slave Court borrowed the titles, oaths, officers, and records of a court of law. The cases and statutes demonstrate its purposeful and strategic role in structuring the legal order imposed upon enslaved people, including forced immigrants in a foreign land.

There is more to be learned from the stories in the records beyond Jack, Mingo, Judith and Bob. The next article involves different issues of the past. Why did a pregnant woman who dressed as a man have to appear in court?12   When men and women were accused of fornication in the early 1700’s, were they treated the same?

Sources

  1. Ernest James Clark Jr., “Aspects of the North Carolina Slave Code, 1715–1860,” 39 North Carolina Historical Review 148, 149–50 (1962), citing John Spencer Bassett, Slavery and Servitude in the Colony of North Carolina 21 (Johns Hopkins Press 1896).
  2. Padgett, supra note 1, at 314, citing The State Records of North Carolina, vol. 23, at 64; Alan D. Watson, “North Carolina Slave Courts, 1715–1785,” 60 North Carolina Historical Review 24, 25–27 (1983); Clark, supra note 1, at 150–51.
  3. An Act concerning Servants and Slaves, ch. 24, §§ XXIX–XXXIV, XLVIII (1741), reprinted in James Iredell, Laws of the State of North-Carolina 87–95 (Edenton, 1791);
  4. Clark, supra note 1, at 148–64; Watson, supra note 2, at 24–27; An Act concerning Servants and Slaves, ch. 24, §§ XIV, XL–XLV (1741).
  5. Watson, supra note 2, at 27–29; An Act concerning Servants and Slaves, ch. 24, §§ XLVIII, L–LI (1741).
  6. An Additional Act to an Act, for Appointing Toll-Books, ch. 5, §§ VII–VIII (1729), reprinted in The State Records of North Carolina, vol. 23, at 114; Padgett, supra note 1, at 307, 311–13; An Act concerning Servants and Slaves, ch. 24, § XXXIV (1741).
  7. Watson, supra note 2, at 31–34.
  8. Id. at 33–35; Milton Ready, The Tar Heel State: A New History of North Carolina 67–68, rev. ed. (University of South Carolina Press 2020).
  9. An Act concerning Servants and Slaves, ch. 24, §§ XLVII–XLVIII (1741); Padgett, supra note 1, at 314–17.
  10. An Additional Act to an Act, Intituled, An Act concerning Servants and Slaves, §§ IV–V (1758),
  11. Padgett, supra note 1, at 314–17, citing The Colonial Records of North Carolina, vol. 8, at 142, and The State Records of North Carolina, vol. 22, at 858.