Past · History of the North Carolina Trial Court System

The Women Before and in the Court in Colonial North Carolina

Ann Durant recovered a seaman's wages in 1673, two centuries before a woman could be licensed to practice.

On May 25, 1673, Ann Durant stood at a court session in Perquimans Precinct on behalf of a seaman named Andrew Ball. The court sat in the home of a council member, as courts in the colony often did, and the setting did not diminish the impact of her representation. Durant recovered the wages owed to Ball for his service aboard a vessel called the Two Brothers.

Two years later, her husband, George, gave her a written power of attorney to sue for his debts and recover his property. Records show that she appeared in court on at least twenty other occasions, for herself or for George, often to collect debts owed to the store she kept. Perhaps because of her success in the lightly populated precinct, she also appeared on behalf of others. The state's Department of Natural and Cultural Resources calls her the first woman known to have acted as an attorney in a North Carolina court.1 It would be 205 more years before Tabitha Anne Holton became the first woman licensed to practice law in North Carolina in January 1878.2

When a woman came before a colonial court, the clerk wrote down her marital status (widow, spinster, single woman, or the wife of a named man) where a man's trade or standing usually appeared. Only occasionally did a woman get an occupation of her own, such as servant, ordinary keeper, or washerwoman, and the labels were not always exact. One married woman was entered as both a wife and a spinster in the same line.3 The label was not just a description, though. The status gave rise to treatment under the law.

Marriage merged a wife's legal existence into her husband's, and she usually could not hold property in her own name, make a binding contract, or sue without her husband joined. A widow or a single woman, however, could do all three. This legal identity applied in the criminal law as well. For example, the law provided that if a woman committed a felony with her husband, "it shall be presumed to be done by his Command, and she shall be excused." Neither ignorance nor a husband was a defense in the law if a married woman was indicted in her own capacity for the offenses of riot, trespass, treason, and murder.4

Women were a small share of the criminal docket. In Donna Spindel's study of the surviving records from 1720 to 1740 (the minutes of three precincts have not been found), women made up about one of nine defendants. A third of the charges against women were for theft. Women rarely faced charges for assault. Women did, however, outpace men for what the records called crimes against morality. Four percent of male defendants faced a charge of adultery or fornication. Meanwhile, for females it was nearly eighteen percent. Spindel suggested the difference may reflect "social attitudes which set different standards of acceptable behavior for men and women."5

Ellinor Mearle's case, a generation earlier, shows what such a prosecution looked like in a precinct court. During the October 1705 term of the Perquimans Precinct Court, she confessed to fornication and adultery. The minutes hold that Mearle was ordered to receive "Ten Stripes on her Back well laid on & pay Costs," the only whipping that Cristina Gillard, in a recent review of twelve years of that court's surviving minutes, found recorded.6

Spindel and Stuart Thomas worked through every surviving higher-court prosecution from 1663 to 1740. They found fifty-two defendants charged with adultery or fornication, twelve of them as couples, and of the rest twenty-one men and seven women. The numbers show that a woman was less likely than her partner to be charged at all, but her outcomes differed once charged. Women were convicted in about sixty-one percent of morality prosecutions, compared with forty-one percent for men, and acquitted less often. Perhaps this was due to the evidence of a pregnancy. The one morals offense in which men and women were convicted at the same high rate was bastardy.7

Twenty-one years after Mearle's stripes to her back, another woman faced the colony's highest court for an offense involving a child. On July 18, 1726, a child was found dead on the shore in Currituck, near the house of Captain Joseph Sanderson. A jury of twelve men was assembled "to Enquire how the Said child came by its Death," and their inquiry led to a ship conveniently named the Virginity. The suspect was "A Woman Called Tom . . . Dressed in Mans Apparel."8 Tom Savage, a servant, proved to be a single twenty-year-old servant named Mary Gorman, who concealed her pregnancy by disguising herself as a man.9

Gorman was tried for the capital offense of murder before the General Court at Edenton on October 25. The next day the jury acquitted her, apparently accepting her account that she had delivered a stillborn child aboard her master's ship and had "privately" thrown the body overboard.10 The record apparently revealed nothing related to a suspected father. Her acquittal was the rule and not the exception. Juries acquitted women charged with murder at about seventy-one percent against twenty-eight for men.11

Women appeared in far greater numbers in civil cases. In a separate study of the higher courts from 1670 to 1730, Spindel found hundreds of women in litigation over debts, property, and estates, most of them there to collect what they were owed.12 The precinct courts show the same pattern on a smaller scale. Gillard counted more than fifty-five women named as parties in twelve years of the Perquimans minutes. In January of 1697, the justices gave Sarah Johnson a judgment for seven hundred pounds of tobacco, which was as good as money and easier to find in a colony without coin.13

Every woman named here was free. An enslaved woman had no name on a bond and no standing to sue for a seaman's wages. After 1715, she answered to a separate tribunal of justices and freeholders that decided guilt and ordered punishment by a bare majority, without a jury or a right of appeal. Her children followed her condition, and a case concerning them would have been argued as a question of the slaveholder's property, not of the mother.14

The colonial court was a place of business and of judgment. It was a reminder of a woman's status and the society's standards. The same court that recorded stripes to the back kept a second ledger, of pregnancies, births, and the cost of children to the parish. Mary Gorman hid from the second ledger in men's clothes. Ellinor Mearle could not commit fornication alone, but she alone appears as the defendant in the surviving record for that precinct. The courts listened to Ann Durant speak on behalf of others and gave Sarah Johnson a judgment payable in tobacco. The minutes tell us what happened in their cases, but only a fraction of what happened in their lives. The surviving records show both how colonial courts judged women and how some women interacted with the courts at the time.

The next article turns to further developments in the state and its court system.

Sources

  1. Mattie Erma E. Parker, "Durant (Durand, Duren), Ann Marwood," in 2 Dictionary of North Carolina Biography (William S. Powell ed., 1986),ncpedia.org/biography/d…, citing Mattie Erma E. Parker, ed., North Carolina Higher-Court Records, 1670–1696 (1968) and 1676–1701 (1971); N.C. Dep't of Natural & Cultural Res., "A Female Lawyer in the 1600s" (May 25, 2016),dncr.nc.gov/blog/2016/0…; N.C. Dep't of Natural & Cultural Res., "Ann Marwood Durant (A-75)" (Dec. 4, 2023),dncr.nc.gov/blog/2023/1….
  2. N.C. Dep't of Natural & Cultural Res., "Tabitha Holton, a First for Tar Heel Courtrooms" (Jan. 9, 2016),dncr.nc.gov/blog/2016/0…; "Holton, Tabitha Anne," NCpedia,ncpedia.org/biography/h….
  3. Donna J. Spindel, "The Administration of Criminal Justice in North Carolina, 1720–1740," 25 Am. J. Legal Hist. 141, 155–57 & n.75 (1981). The woman entered as both wife and spinster was Susanna McGowen, 1725, "wife of the said Bartholomew, Spinster," 2 Colonial Records of North Carolina 588 (William L. Saunders ed., 1886).
  4. Spindel, supra note 3, at 157 (quoting James Davis, The Office and Authority of a Justice of the Peace 179–81 (1774)).
  5. Spindel, supra note 3, at 143 (the sample and the missing precinct records), 157 (women 11.1 percent of defendants), 159 (theft 32.1 percent of female prosecutions; adultery and fornication charged against 4.0 percent of male and 17.9 percent of female defendants; quotation).
  6. Cristina Gillard, "Analysis of North Carolina Colonial Records: Perquimans Precinct Court," Monarch Review 25–28 (2020),methodist.edu/wp-conten…, summarizing Perquimans Precinct Court Minutes, Oct. 9–10, 1705, in 1 Colonial Records of North Carolina 624–27 (William L. Saunders ed., 1886). The quotation and the count of whippings are as reported by Gillard.
  7. Donna J. Spindel & Stuart W. Thomas, Jr., "Crime and Society in North Carolina, 1663–1740," 49 J. S. Hist. 223, 240–42 & tbl. 7 (1983).
  8. Spindel, supra note 3, at 141, quoting the coroner's inquest of July 18, 1726, and King v. Mary Gorman, October 1726, General Court Records, Criminal Papers, 1726, State Archives of North Carolina.
  9. Spindel, supra note 3, at 141, 159.
  10. Spindel, supra note 3, at 141.
  11. Spindel, supra note 3, at 159; Spindel & Thomas, supra note 7, at 240–41 & tbl. 7.
  12. Donna J. Spindel, "Women's Civil Actions in the North Carolina Higher Courts, 1670–1730," 71 N.C. Hist. Rev. 151 (1994).
  13. Gillard, supra note 6, at 25–28, summarizing Perquimans Precinct Court Minutes, Jan. 11–13, 1697, in 1 Colonial Records of North Carolina 478–85.
  14. James A. Padgett, "The Status of Slaves in Colonial North Carolina," 14 J. Negro Hist. 300, 314, 324 (1929). See also Article 2 of this series.